Reality Check: Did Ben get his numbers right on the Bush tax cut - Cincinnati News, Weather, Sports from FOX19 NOW-WXIX

Reality Check: Did Ben get his numbers right on the Bush tax cuts?

Lisa emailed in response to my Reality Check on how our nation got into so much debt and she wasn't happy with what she heard.

Here is a portion of what she had to say.

"I would say that news organizations who dumb down (over simplify) the news in order to create an illusion of balance, or what I call faux balance, in the guise of complete fact checking, is a major reason the public is so misinformed."-Lisa, Alexandria, KY

So what did I mis-inform you about?  Lisa says when I say the revenues under President Bush rose even after the Bush tax cuts is "wholly inaccurate" because "the only honest and accurate measure of revenue is a percentage of G.D.P. Revenue has averaged 18% of  G.D.P. since 1970.  It was below 15% as Bush left office.  The bottom line is revenue as a share of G.D.P. was lower every single year of the bush presidency than it was in 2000."

So lets look at her statement.  First, that revenue has averaged 18% G.D.P. since 1970.  That is true.  And it is also true that "it was below 15% as President Bush left office."

But what Lisa doesn't take into account is that when President Bush left office, we were in the midst of a recession, which was caused by the housing crisis and Wall Street mess. 

So lets talk about the whole story of tax revenue percentage of G.D.P.

A graph from the Congressional Budget Office, shows the past 30 years, from 1981 to 2012. revenue percentage of G.D.P. the standard Lisa says I should have used.

Lisa says that the 40 year average for percentage of revenue to G.D.P. is 18 percent.

Well, in 2006, three years after the Bush tax cuts went into effect, revenue was 18.4% of G.D.P. under President Bush. That is in line with where we were a decade before under President Clinton in 1995 at 18.5%.  And a decade before that in 1987 under President Reagan at 18.4%. 

Lisa also states that  "revenue as a share of G.D.P. was lower every single year of the Bush presidency than it was in 2000."  Again that statement is true but not the whole story and to tie that to the Bush tax cuts is questionable, as 2000 was an anomaly.  Back to that graph from the CBO.  Revenue to G.D.P. was higher in 2000 than it was in any year in the past 30 years.

2005, 06 and 07, revenue percentage to G.D.P. is on the rise with three consecutive years.  The housing and Wall Street crisis of 2008 ends that streak.

Here's what you need to know..

There is one more thing on that graph that you need to see.

In the past 30 years we have had only 4 years when our tax revenue to G.D.P. percentage surpassed our expenses percentage to G.D.P.  Those years were 98, 99, 2000 and 2001. 

Lisa says I am over simplifying the issue.  But the bottom-line is that our problem is pretty simple.  As long as we as a nation are spending and borrowing more, or in this case vastly more,  than we take in, the country is in serious trouble.

And that is Reality Check.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/9/90/Revenue_and_Expense_to_GDP_Chart_1993_-_2008.png

  • FOX19 HeadlinesMore>>

  • State fair officials work to reassure visitors about safety

    State fair officials work to reassure visitors about safety

    Monday, July 23 2018 1:47 PM EDT2018-07-23 17:47:27 GMT
    There was a ride malfunction at the Ohio State Fair on Wednesday. (Source: Narkatta)There was a ride malfunction at the Ohio State Fair on Wednesday. (Source: Narkatta)

    State officials are working to reassure visitors the Ohio State Fair will be safe a year after a catastrophic ride failure left an 18-year-old dead and seven others injured.

    Full Story >

    State officials are working to reassure visitors the 2018 Ohio State Fair will be safe after a catastrophic ride failure left an 18-year-old dead and seven others injured last year.

    Full Story >
  • Uber suspends driver who live-streamed St. Louis passengers

    Uber suspends driver who live-streamed St. Louis passengers

    Sunday, July 22 2018 9:59 PM EDT2018-07-23 01:59:54 GMT
    Monday, July 23 2018 1:47 PM EDT2018-07-23 17:47:20 GMT
    The driver allegedly livestreamed almost all 700 rides to his Twitch channel. (Source: Abhijit Bhaduri/Flickr, File)The driver allegedly livestreamed almost all 700 rides to his Twitch channel. (Source: Abhijit Bhaduri/Flickr, File)

    Ride-sharing company Uber has suspended a driver who recorded hundreds of St. Louis-area riders without their permission and streamed the live video online.

    Full Story >

    Ride-sharing company Uber has suspended a driver who recorded hundreds of St. Louis-area riders without their permission and streamed the live video online.

    Full Story >
  • Deadly LA market shooting started with domestic feud

    Deadly LA market shooting started with domestic feud

    Monday, July 23 2018 1:25 AM EDT2018-07-23 05:25:22 GMT
    Monday, July 23 2018 1:47 PM EDT2018-07-23 17:47:15 GMT
    (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes). A makeshift memorial of flowers, candles and notes grows on the sidewalk outside the Los Feliz Trader Joe's store in Los Angeles, Sunday, July 22, 2018. A day earlier, Trader Joe's employee Melyda Corado was shot and kille...(AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes). A makeshift memorial of flowers, candles and notes grows on the sidewalk outside the Los Feliz Trader Joe's store in Los Angeles, Sunday, July 22, 2018. A day earlier, Trader Joe's employee Melyda Corado was shot and kille...

    The violence began when the suspect shot his grandmother several times after she complained about his having too many television sets on, according to a relative.

    Full Story >

    The violence began when the suspect shot his grandmother several times after she complained about his having too many television sets on, according to a relative.

    Full Story >
Powered by Frankly