Reality Check: Is Social Security a Ponzi scheme? - Cincinnati News, FOX19-WXIX TV

Reality Check: Is Social Security a Ponzi scheme?

(FOX19) - In his book "Fed Up" Texas Governor Rick Perry wrote that Social Security is an illegal ponzi scheme.

During the debate Wednesday night, he was again asked about that comments and the Texas Governor didn't back down.

He again said that the program is a ponzi scheme and added this.

"and it is a monstrous lie. It is a ponzi scheme to tell our kids that are 25 or 30 years old today, You pay into a program that is going to be there."  said Gov. Perry.

So, is social security a ponzi scheme?  To begin with, lets talk about what a ponzi scheme actually is.

Named after Boston con man Charles Ponzi, it is a fraudulent investment operation.  In its essential design it's a con.  Because the scheme requires an ever-increasing number of new participants to pay off earlier investors, they inevitably collapse.

Is that social security?

It is true that Social Security depends on future investors to pay for current ones.  But Social Security isn't an individual investment plan.

It's a government insurance plan that offers seniors a predictable income.  Retirees do depend on future workers to pay their Social Security benefits, though unlike a ponzi scheme, nobody pretends otherwise.

Under the programs design, if you die before you become eligible, your estate doesn't get your money.  If you live longer than average, you get more than what you paid in.

Social Security is also referred to as a ponzi scheme because money is taken out of the Social Security Trust Fund and moved to treasury bonds taken from one place and used in another.

The lie, says Governor Perry is that Social Security will be there in the future.  Unlike regular investments, participants in social security don't own their accounts.  For years, Social Security collected more in payroll taxes than it paid out in benefits, but that is no longer the case.

The program is now drawing on the surplus accumulated during those years.

By 2036, the program's actuaries predict, Social Security will have exhausted its reserves and will only be able to pay 77% of promised benefits.

Here's what you need to know.

Charles Ponzi's scheme was unsustainable because the basic math of his system required ever increasing and unrealistic numbers of investors.

But the reality is that Social Security's system is also unsustainable, at least the way it is currently structured.

That is because for those 25 and 30 year olds, who Governor Perry spoke of, they will have to support an increasing number of retirees who have much fewer workers to support them.

That math doesn't work.

And that is Reality Check.

Copyright 2011 FOX19. All Rights Reserved.

  • FOX19 HeadlinesMore>>

  • LIST: Road closures, Red Cross flood shelters

    LIST: Road closures, Red Cross flood shelters

    Friday, February 23 2018 5:05 PM EST2018-02-23 22:05:21 GMT
    A car is stuck in floodwaters on Carrel Street near Kellogg Avenue Friday. (FOX19 NOW/Matt Wood)A car is stuck in floodwaters on Carrel Street near Kellogg Avenue Friday. (FOX19 NOW/Matt Wood)

    List of road closures due to flooding.

    Full Story >

    List of road closures due to flooding.

    Full Story >
  • After school shooting, Florida leaders propose new gun laws

    After school shooting, Florida leaders propose new gun laws

    Thursday, February 22 2018 11:34 PM EST2018-02-23 04:34:46 GMT
    Friday, February 23 2018 4:58 PM EST2018-02-23 21:58:43 GMT
    (Mike Stocker/South Florida Sun-Sentinel via AP). Mourners attend the funeral service for Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School assistant football coach, Aaron Feis. at the Church by the Glades in Coral Springs, Fla., Thursday, Feb. 22. 2018. Football p...(Mike Stocker/South Florida Sun-Sentinel via AP). Mourners attend the funeral service for Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School assistant football coach, Aaron Feis. at the Church by the Glades in Coral Springs, Fla., Thursday, Feb. 22. 2018. Football p...

    'Abject breakdown on all levels': Florida high school where ex-student accused of fatally shooting 17 people reopening to teachers Friday amid revelations an armed officer on campus did nothing to stop suspect,...

    Full Story >

    'Abject breakdown on all levels': Florida high school where ex-student accused of fatally shooting 17 people reopening to teachers Friday amid revelations an armed officer on campus did nothing to stop suspect, other issues.

    Full Story >
  • 2nd Russian athlete tests positive for doping at Olympics

    2nd Russian athlete tests positive for doping at Olympics

    Friday, February 23 2018 5:34 AM EST2018-02-23 10:34:42 GMT
    Friday, February 23 2018 4:58 PM EST2018-02-23 21:58:10 GMT
    (AP Photo/Michael Sohn). Driver Nadezhda Sergeeva and Anastasia Kocherzhova of the Olympic Athletes of Russia take a curve in their third heat during the women's two-man bobsled final at the 2018 Winter Olympics in Pyeongchang, South Korea, Wednesday, ...(AP Photo/Michael Sohn). Driver Nadezhda Sergeeva and Anastasia Kocherzhova of the Olympic Athletes of Russia take a curve in their third heat during the women's two-man bobsled final at the 2018 Winter Olympics in Pyeongchang, South Korea, Wednesday, ...

    A second Russian athlete has failed a doping test at the Pyeongchang Games, a day before the International Olympic Committee's executive board is to decide whether to reinstate the country for Sunday's closing...

    Full Story >

    A second Russian athlete has failed a doping test at the Pyeongchang Games, a day before the International Olympic Committee's executive board is to decide whether to reinstate the country for Sunday's closing ceremony.

    Full Story >
Powered by Frankly