CINCINNATI, OH (FOX19) - The trial of a former Bengal who was indicted for having sex with a teenage girl continued Wednesday with testimony from the alleged victim. The defense has not yet had the chance to cross-examine the teen.
First to take the stand Wednesday was the teen's father who recalled the first time he had heard about their sexual relationship.
"My daughter told me, she says 'Dad, there's something else I need to tell you because I can't keep it anymore.' I said 'What's going on?' She says 'Me and Nate have been having sex' and I go, 'What?'," the father recalled.
On the stand, the teen stated that Webster had told her he loved her in October 2009, a date the teen says she highlighted on her calendar.
"He said he normally doesn't do this and I'm going to break the man code but 'I love you'," the teen recalled.
During Wednesday's testimony the prosecution played a recording of a sequence of interactions between the teen and Webster which had been taped by police in the spring of 2011.
In the tapes, the teen brings up a fall 2009 incident where she and Webster had been found together in his car by the teen's mother.
Voice of teen: "I know that one time during Halloween where I was with you and then we had to pretend like I was with somebody else… I know that scared you."
Voice of Webster: "When your momma and daddy jumped out of the car?"
Voice of Teen: "What was that in like October two years ago? Was that about that time, like two years ago?"
Voice of Webster: "Yeah, that [expletive] was scary."
The prosecution alleges the relationship took place over a year and a half timeframe beginning in June 2009 when the teen was 15 years old and Webster was in his early 30's. They argue that Webster was a "predator" that "coerced" the teen into a sexual relationship. Prosecuting attorney Seth Tieger says Webster often provided the teen with marijuana before engaging in sex acts. Tieger stated the former Bengal player also got the teen a tattoo that included a heart with his initial that has since been covered up.
The defense argues the sexual relationship did not begin until the "troubled" teen was 16 and that their sexual interactions were "consensual".
The teen is the daughter of a former Bengals coach.
Webster was traded to the Bengals in 2004 after being drafted by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 2000.
He signed as a free agent with the Denver Broncos in 2006. He hasn't played since 2008.
Last year, he was hired as the defensive coordinator for the Bellevue High School football team.
The trial will continue Thursday as the defense cross examines the alleged teen victim. The rest of the taped conversations are also expected to be played Thursday morning.