3 super-close presidential elections: Beyond Bush v. Gore - Cincinnati News, FOX19-WXIX TV

3 super-close presidential elections

President George W. Bush ©WhiteHouse.gov President George W. Bush ©WhiteHouse.gov

By Elisa D. Keller

(FRANKLY) – Come election night, most Americans hope for a clear-cut presidential winner – somebody definitively ushered into office by an enthusiastic majority of voters.

But for politicians and the general public alike, there is always one nightmare scenario hovering in the back of their minds. What if the voting tally is so close that Americans will have to wait days, weeks or even months to find out which candidate won? And, even worse, what if the numbers tell you both people won?  

Thanks to the variances between the Electoral College and popular vote count, it's a distinct – if rare – possibility. A candidate can receive more votes nation-wide (the popular vote), but if he doesn't win enough states to carry the Electoral College he won't win the election.

Here are three of the closest results in presidential elections.  


1876: Rutherford B. Hayes v. Samuel Tilden

One of the most hotly contested elections in American history, Democrat Samuel Tilden won the popular vote by nearly 250,000 votes, and was leading Republican Rutherford B. Hayes by 19 votes in the Electoral College votes with only a few southern states yet to report.

Unfortunately for Tilden, those states' votes tallied 20, and after days of argument between the parties, and a purported deal to free those southern states of any remaining post-Civil War federal soldiers, the remaining votes went to Hayes. In the end, Tilden lost the Presidency by a single Electoral College vote.  


1888: Benjamin Harrison v. Grover Cleveland

It may be hard to believe, but only 12 short years after the Hayes-Tilden popular vote/Electoral College division, it happened all over again. This time, sitting President Grover Cleveland, a Democrat, won the popular vote by a scant 90,000 votes, but Republican Benjamin Harrison had a 37 vote advantage in the Electoral College, thanks to him carrying Cleveland's home state by 1 percentage point.

The kind of split election result that made Harrison president would not happen again for 112 years.


2000: George W. Bush v. Al Gore

Thanks to this epically close election, phrases like "butterfly ballot" and "hanging chad" entered the American pop culture lexicon, and the electoral process was mired in red tape for over a month. 

Democrat Al Gore lead the popular vote over Republican George W. Bush by some 500,000 votes, but the race really came down to Florida. With 25 Electoral College votes hanging in the balance, a few hundred Floridian votes would make the difference.

After a ruling by the Supreme Court to halt all recounts, Bush was named the winner, serving as Commander in Chief during some of America's most difficult crises, including 9/11 and the Iraq and Afghanistan wars. Al Gore, on the other hand, would go on to win a Nobel Peace Prize and an Academy Award instead.



Elisa D. Keller is Content Editor for Frankly Inc.

*DISCLAIMER*: The information contained in or provided through this site section is intended for general consumer understanding and education only and is not intended to be and is not a substitute for professional advice. Use of this site section and any information contained on or provided through this site section is at your own risk and any information contained on or provided through this site section is provided on an "as is" basis without any representations or warranties.
  • FOX19 HeadlinesMore>>

  • 5 dead after tornado, flooding from central US storms

    5 dead after tornado, flooding from central US storms

    Sunday, February 25 2018 2:25 AM EST2018-02-25 07:25:46 GMT
    Sunday, February 25 2018 8:18 PM EST2018-02-26 01:18:22 GMT
    (Liz Dufour/The Cincinnati Enquirer via AP). A view from the Central Bridge shows the flooding from the Ohio River  Saturday, Feb. 24, 2018 in Cincinnati.  Forecasters expected the Ohio River could reach levels not seen since the region's deadly 1997 f...(Liz Dufour/The Cincinnati Enquirer via AP). A view from the Central Bridge shows the flooding from the Ohio River Saturday, Feb. 24, 2018 in Cincinnati. Forecasters expected the Ohio River could reach levels not seen since the region's deadly 1997 f...

    A man in northeast Arkansas and a woman in south central Kentucky both were killed as the storm that also included strong winds, hail and heavy rain that triggered flooding muscled its way through the area, according to authorities.

    Full Story >

    A man in northeast Arkansas and a woman in south central Kentucky both were killed as the storm that also included strong winds, hail and heavy rain that triggered flooding muscled its way through the area, according to authorities.

    Full Story >
  • Elsmere man facing attempted murder charge in Covington officer shooting

    Elsmere man facing attempted murder charge in Covington officer shooting

    Sunday, February 25 2018 8:07 PM EST2018-02-26 01:07:34 GMT
    Brad Anthony Williams, 41, is facing multiple charges, including attempted murder (Kenton County Jail)Brad Anthony Williams, 41, is facing multiple charges, including attempted murder (Kenton County Jail)

    An Elsmere man is being charged with attempted murder in an officer involved shooting at a home in Covington.

    Full Story >

    An Elsmere man is being charged with attempted murder in an officer involved shooting at a home in Covington.

    Full Story >
  • Political end to Olympics: NKorea offers talks with US

    Political end to Olympics: NKorea offers talks with US

    Sunday, February 25 2018 2:16 AM EST2018-02-25 07:16:08 GMT
    Sunday, February 25 2018 8:06 PM EST2018-02-26 01:06:59 GMT
    (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky). A volunteer walks in a foggy Pyeongchang Olympic Plaza during the 2018 Winter Olympics in Pyeongchang, South Korea, Saturday, Feb. 24, 2018.(AP Photo/Patrick Semansky). A volunteer walks in a foggy Pyeongchang Olympic Plaza during the 2018 Winter Olympics in Pyeongchang, South Korea, Saturday, Feb. 24, 2018.

    Pyeongchang closes its chapter of the modern Olympics on Sunday night with tales of detente and competitive grit and volunteerism and verve.

    Full Story >

    Pyeongchang closes its chapter of the modern Olympics on Sunday night with tales of detente and competitive grit and volunteerism and verve.

    Full Story >
  • ElectionsMore>>

  • California Democratic Party won't endorse Dianne Feinstein

    California Democratic Party won't endorse Dianne Feinstein

    Sunday, February 25 2018 1:26 PM EST2018-02-25 18:26:18 GMT
    Sunday, February 25 2018 8:18 PM EST2018-02-26 01:18:33 GMT
    (AP Photo/Denis Poroy). Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., speaks at the 2018 California Democrats State Convention Saturday, Feb. 24, 2018, in San Diego.(AP Photo/Denis Poroy). Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., speaks at the 2018 California Democrats State Convention Saturday, Feb. 24, 2018, in San Diego.
    U.S. Sen. Dianne Feinstein has failed to win the official endorsement of the California Democratic Party as she seeks her fifth term in Washington.Full Story >
    U.S. Sen. Dianne Feinstein has failed to win the official endorsement of the California Democratic Party as she seeks her fifth term in Washington.Full Story >
  • Govs fear for election security amid Russian cyberattacks

    Govs fear for election security amid Russian cyberattacks

    Sunday, February 25 2018 2:47 PM EST2018-02-25 19:47:14 GMT
    Sunday, February 25 2018 8:18 PM EST2018-02-26 01:18:08 GMT
    (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana). Washington Gov. Jay Inslee speaks at the panel Pathways to Prosperity during the National Governor Association 2018 winter meeting, on Sunday, Feb. 25, 2018, in Washington.(AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana). Washington Gov. Jay Inslee speaks at the panel Pathways to Prosperity during the National Governor Association 2018 winter meeting, on Sunday, Feb. 25, 2018, in Washington.
    Govs fear for election security as Russian cyberattacks target midterm elections.Full Story >
    Govs fear for election security as Russian cyberattacks target midterm elections.Full Story >
  • Q&A: What the battle of memos on FBI surveillance showed

    Q&A: What the battle of memos on FBI surveillance showed

    Sunday, February 25 2018 1:06 PM EST2018-02-25 18:06:39 GMT
    Sunday, February 25 2018 8:17 PM EST2018-02-26 01:17:58 GMT
    (AP Photo/Alex Brandon, File). FILE- In this Feb. 5, 2018, file photo, Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., ranking member of the House Committee on Intelligence, pauses while speaking during a media availability after a closed-door meeting of the House Intelli...(AP Photo/Alex Brandon, File). FILE- In this Feb. 5, 2018, file photo, Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., ranking member of the House Committee on Intelligence, pauses while speaking during a media availability after a closed-door meeting of the House Intelli...
    Questions and answers about what was learned from the battle of classified memos on the Russia investigation and why it matters.Full Story >
    Questions and answers about what was learned from the battle of classified memos on the Russia investigation and why it matters.Full Story >
Powered by Frankly