ACLU lawsuit: Controversial Indiana nativity scene violates Cons - Cincinnati News, Weather, Sports from FOX19 NOW-WXIX

ACLU lawsuit: Controversial Indiana nativity scene violates Constitution

BROOKVILLE, IN (FOX19) -

The American Civil Liberties Union filed a lawsuit Tuesday, contending that a Brookville, Ind. nativity scene displayed on its courthouse lawn violates the United States Constitution. 

The lawsuit, filed Tuesday in the U.S. District Court in Indianapolis, says that the display "represents an endorsement of religion and has principal effect of advancing religion, and it therefore runs afoul of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment to the United States Constitution." 

This comes just one week after FOX19 NOW spoke to residents of the community who came together in support of the nativity scene, which has been on display in the city for more than 50 years.

[RELATED: Community responds to Christmas nativity scene controversy]

And while many city residents appreciate the display, at least one person doesn't. 

In 2010, a complainant contacted the Freedom from Religion Foundation in Madison, Wis. who now asks the county commissioners every year to take it down."FFRF has no problem with religious displays on private property. It's only when the government is endorsing a religious message as is the case here that they are violating the constitution,” says Sam Grover, Staff Attorney for Freedom from Religion Foundation.

According to The Associated Press, the Franklin County Commissioner says the federal complaint violates the county's rights of freedom of expression and freedom of religion.

County Commissioner told the AP that the county isn't opposed to allowing other religious groups to erect displays as long as they are tasteful. 

But the lawsuit asks that the court to ban Franklin County from displaying the scene in the lawn in front of the courthouse. 

Copyright 2014 WXIX. All rights reserved.

  • FOX19 HeadlinesMore>>

  • Donations, volunteering surge at border asylum-seeker center

    Donations, volunteering surge at border asylum-seeker center

    Monday, June 25 2018 12:25 AM EDT2018-06-25 04:25:33 GMT
    Monday, June 25 2018 3:45 PM EDT2018-06-25 19:45:59 GMT
    (AP Photo/Manuel Valdes). In this photograph taken June 24, 2018, a Catholic Charities of Rio Grande Valley staffer and volunteers unload boxes of donations on to a cart at a storage facility in McAllen, Texas. A rest center for asylum-seekers in the T...(AP Photo/Manuel Valdes). In this photograph taken June 24, 2018, a Catholic Charities of Rio Grande Valley staffer and volunteers unload boxes of donations on to a cart at a storage facility in McAllen, Texas. A rest center for asylum-seekers in the T...

    The boxes started arriving as people across the country began to learn about President Donald Trump's policy of separating children from their families.

    Full Story >

    The boxes started arriving as people across the country began to learn about President Donald Trump's policy of separating children from their families.

    Full Story >
  • In sign of detente, North Korea skips annual anti-US rally

    In sign of detente, North Korea skips annual anti-US rally

    Monday, June 25 2018 4:04 AM EDT2018-06-25 08:04:07 GMT
    Monday, June 25 2018 3:26 PM EDT2018-06-25 19:26:43 GMT
    (AP Photo/Jon Chol Jin, File). FILE - In this June 25, 2017, file photo, tens of thousands of men and women pump their fists in the air and chant as they carry placards with anti-American propaganda slogans at Pyongyang's central Kim Il Sung Square, in...(AP Photo/Jon Chol Jin, File). FILE - In this June 25, 2017, file photo, tens of thousands of men and women pump their fists in the air and chant as they carry placards with anti-American propaganda slogans at Pyongyang's central Kim Il Sung Square, in...

    For the first time in years, North Korea isn't holding its annual "anti-U.S. imperialism" mass rally marking the start of the Korean War.

    Full Story >

    For the first time in years, North Korea isn't holding its annual "anti-U.S. imperialism" mass rally marking the start of the Korean War.

    Full Story >
  • US prosecutors cancel Stormy Daniels meeting in Cohen probe

    US prosecutors cancel Stormy Daniels meeting in Cohen probe

    Sunday, June 24 2018 9:15 PM EDT2018-06-25 01:15:00 GMT
    Monday, June 25 2018 3:15 PM EDT2018-06-25 19:15:42 GMT
    Monday's interview with prosecutors from the U.S. attorney's office in Manhattan is in preparation for a possible grand jury appearance as they work to assemble a case against Trump's longtime personal lawyer, Michael Cohen, the person said. (Source: CNN)Monday's interview with prosecutors from the U.S. attorney's office in Manhattan is in preparation for a possible grand jury appearance as they work to assemble a case against Trump's longtime personal lawyer, Michael Cohen, the person said. (Source: CNN)

    Porn actress Stormy Daniels will meet with federal prosecutors in New York who are investigating President Donald Trump's former personal attorney.

    Full Story >

    Porn actress Stormy Daniels will meet with federal prosecutors in New York who are investigating President Donald Trump's former personal attorney.

    Full Story >
Powered by Frankly