Convict’s own court filing leads to new discovery, reckless homicide charge against him

Scott Wilson was convicted of assaulting the 6-week-old infant in 1985.
Published: Dec. 2, 2022 at 3:12 PM EST|Updated: Dec. 3, 2022 at 8:52 PM EST
Email This Link
Share on Pinterest
Share on LinkedIn

CLERMONT COUNTY, Ohio (WXIX) - A man’s request to have court records sealed led to his indictment on charges in connection with the 2006 death of a girl who was assaulted as an infant, a prosecutor says.

In 1985, Scott Wilson, 57, was convicted of assaulting 6-week-old Heather Gentry by shaking her, according to Clermont County Prosecutor Mark Tekulve.

At the time of the assault, Wilson was in his own residence with Heather and her mother, Toni Thoroughman.

The alleged crime occurred on Jan. 5, 1985, when Thoroughman was taking a shower and Heather was “peacefully” sleeping.

While in the shower, Tekulve says Thoroughman heard Heather crying, but the crying abruptly stopped.

Later that day, Heather was unresponsive.

Thoroughman took her daughter to a pediatrician, who then told her to take Heather to Cincinnati Children’s Hospital, Tekulve said.

Two days later, the Clermont County Sheriff’s Office was alerted about Heather’s injuries and began investigating.

According to Tekulve, Wilson admitted to shaking Heather to a Clermont County detective.

Wilson was originally charged with felonious assault, but a jury convicted him of assault, the prosecutor explained.

In December 2006, Heather died from her injuries that were allegedly caused by Wilson.

An autopsy confirmed the cause of death was ultimately due to the late effects of blunt trauma to the head, Tekulve said.

Heather’s life was not easy, as Prosecutor Tekulve explained.

For her 22 years of life, Heather was confined to a bed, unable to walk or communicate, and needed a feeding tube and “around-the-clock care,” the prosecutor said.

As Heather’s father, Terry Gentry, explains, her death did not only mean he lost a daughter, but the entire family lost someone.

“If she would’ve been healthy and this didn’t happen, I have three children that would’ve loved to have a sister,” he says. “That was taken from all of them, not just me, my entire family.”

Heather’s case was closed, however, 37 years later, it was reopened when Wilson made a request to the court.

In August 2022, the case was looked at again by the Clermont County Sheriff’s Office and the Clermont County Prosecutor’s Office after Wilson requested to have his records sealed, according to Clermont County Assistant Prosecutor Zachary Zipperer.

Zipperer says if Wilson never applied to have his records sealed, then the prosecutor’s office may have never uncovered Heather’s death.

Wilson, now 57, was indicted Friday on charges of reckless homicide and involuntary manslaughter, according to the Clermont County Prosecutor’s Office.

Investigators are currently working to obtain evidence and statements from people who were aware of the incident.

The news of Wilson’s indictment has been tough for Gentry.

“I had to put my little girl in the ground at 22 years old, so for this all to reemerge and come back, it’s set me back quite a bit. it’s messed with my nerves,” Gentry said.

Wilson is currently out of jail on a recognizance bond, court records show.

See a spelling or grammar error in our story? Please include the title when you click here to report it.